催稿信怎么寫(xiě)確實(shí)有很大學(xué)問(wèn),我的導(dǎo)師曾經(jīng)就跟我講過(guò)一次他的經(jīng)歷,博士畢業(yè)前要發(fā)論文也挺急的,但是據(jù)描述論文還挺不錯(cuò),后來(lái)發(fā)了,具體期刊名字不記得了但是影響因子是4點(diǎn)多……可想而知論文還是很不錯(cuò)的,最初第一次投了一本期刊,看狀態(tài)寫(xiě)underreview,但是等了4個(gè)星期還沒(méi)回復(fù),就寫(xiě)了一封催稿信,當(dāng)然很委婉,然后人家回復(fù)underreview,然后又等,這一等又是一個(gè)月啦……導(dǎo)師忍不住了又來(lái)了一封催稿信,結(jié)果人家直接拒了,然后說(shuō)試試投其它的雜志……不知道是真的文章不符合要求(可能性不大),還是主編被搞的不耐煩了……
就總結(jié)一點(diǎn)寫(xiě)催稿信的經(jīng)驗(yàn)吧~~
直接問(wèn)稿件現(xiàn)在的狀態(tài),外國(guó)人通常比較直接,想問(wèn)什么直接說(shuō),但是語(yǔ)氣一定要委婉,如果回復(fù)你under review或者withedtor之類(lèi)的就再繼續(xù)等等耐心一點(diǎn),還有一點(diǎn)就是看清楚審稿周期,一般期刊的網(wǎng)頁(yè)都會(huì)寫(xiě)審稿周期多久,一般都在3個(gè)月到6個(gè)月的,投稿特別是英文稿一定要有耐心,一些影響因子比較高的雜志更是,他們的編輯每天要處理的稿件都非常多,所以即使寫(xiě)催稿信一定要語(yǔ)氣委婉!
找了一些模板 ,大家可以參考下~~
Dear Dr. XXXXXXX,
Wesubmitted a manuscript (manuscript ID) to “XXXX journal” on X-X-X.You are the executive editor. We have not, yet, received anycomment or decision about the submission. Please let us know anyfurther information of the reviewing process at your earliestconvenience. Many thanks!
Sincerely yours,XXXXXXXXXXX
Dear professor XXX,
We submitted the paper (No.xxx) entitled “XXXXXX”to you for publication in the XXXXX three months ago. Could yougive us an update on the current status of our submission? Anyinformation will be greatly appreciated.Thank you very much foryour consideration.With best regards
Sincerely yours,XXXXX
更委婉一點(diǎn)的~~
Dear Prof. ×××:
Sorry for disturbing you. I am not sure if it is the righttime to contact you to inquire about the status of my submittedmanuscript titled “Paper Title”. (ID: 文章稿號(hào)), although the status of“With Editor” has been lasting for more than two months, sincesubmitted to journal three months ago. I am just wondering that mymanuscript has been sent to reviewers or not?
I would be greatly appreciated if you could spend some of yourtime check the status for us. I am very pleased to hear from you onthe reviewer’s comments.
Thank you very much for your consideration.
Best regards!
Yours sincerely,
××××××
Corresponding author:
Name: ×××
E-mail: ××××@××××
dear prof.×:
e-mail:×@×
thank you for your letter and for the rev iewers'commentsconcerning our manuscript entitled"paper title"(id:文章稿號(hào)).thosecomments are all valuable and very helpful for revising andimproving our paper,as well as the important guiding significanceto our researches.we have studied comments carefully and have madecorrection whelloch we hope meet with approval.revised portion aremarked in red in the paper.the main corrections in the paper andthe responds to the reviewer's comments are as flowing:
we tried our best to improve the manuscript and made somechanges in the manuscript.these changes will not influence thecontent and framework of the paper.and here we did not list thechanges but marked in red in revised paper.
又一個(gè)參考:
Dear ***
We submitted a paper entitled " **** " (Manuscript number: **)on Feb 28, 2005. About one month has past, but the manuscript isstill under review. I am quite anxious for the current statusregarding our paper. And how long dose the review progress last,usually? When can we receive your decisionletter?
Looking forward to yours reply!
Kind regards.
Yours sincerely,
純屬個(gè)人觀點(diǎn),若有不當(dāng)之處,敬請(qǐng)指正!
通常,負(fù)責(zé)的審稿人一般會(huì)在論文審閱期限前交付雜志社,當(dāng)然也有部分審稿人未能及時(shí)提交審稿意見(jiàn),這樣就有了“催稿”一詞。催稿雖然表明上是審稿人未及時(shí)返回意見(jiàn)所導(dǎo)致作者進(jìn)行催促的行為,我覺(jué)得其實(shí)包括兩塊:(1)論文實(shí)際水平;(2)審稿人態(tài)度。
如果論文寫(xiě)作流暢,能夠吸引審稿人,俗稱(chēng)能“吊胃口”,那么就會(huì)大大縮小審稿時(shí)間。根據(jù)本人的審稿體會(huì),如果一篇論文寫(xiě)得很好,就好比一篇精彩的小說(shuō)引人入勝,審稿人通常會(huì)一口氣讀完,這樣審稿意見(jiàn)返回自然也迅速。這就要求我們?cè)谔峤徽撐牡臅r(shí)候?qū)⒄撐淖鲎?,力求完美?/div> 其次,一般審稿人都是大學(xué)副高以上職稱(chēng)的老師,教學(xué)科研任務(wù)等繁重,他們通常會(huì)根據(jù)自己手頭事情的優(yōu)先等級(jí)來(lái)處理事務(wù),而且審稿通常由于報(bào)酬低甚至義務(wù)工作等因素使得審稿只是在其空閑時(shí)間進(jìn)行。因此,通常建議大家不要催稿,理由如下:
1)編輯部采編系統(tǒng)通常有自動(dòng)催稿功能;
2)未到審稿時(shí)間催稿,一來(lái)給審稿人來(lái)帶壓力,造成審稿人草草審稿,影響審稿最后錄用;二來(lái)會(huì)對(duì)編輯產(chǎn)生不良印象,以為作者質(zhì)疑編輯的工作態(tài)度等;
3)即使最糟糕情況,系統(tǒng)催稿后還未收到審稿意見(jiàn),編輯部通常會(huì)更換審稿人。
當(dāng)然,過(guò)了審稿時(shí)間,我們可以發(fā)一封客氣的mail給編輯,問(wèn)一下審稿狀態(tài),而不是直白白的進(jìn)行催稿——“曲線(xiàn)救國(guó)”,以表示作者對(duì)論文的重視。
不過(guò),據(jù)我周?chē)驼J(rèn)識(shí)朋友的反饋,通常情況下,催稿的結(jié)果一般是負(fù)面的,甚至直接將論文扼殺。我曾經(jīng)也催過(guò)稿,編輯告訴我,他們不會(huì)直接與審稿人聯(lián)系,而是系統(tǒng)自動(dòng)發(fā)催稿,或者自動(dòng)換審稿人?;蛟S這也是他們期刊的規(guī)定吧,避免審稿人與編輯的直接接觸。
附催稿信模板:
(1)
Dear Editor:
We submitted a manuscript (manuscript ID) to “***journal”on***. You are the executive editor. We have not, yet, received anycomment or decision about the submission. Please let us know anyfurther information of the reviewing process at your earliestconvenience.
Many thanks.
Sincerely yours,
(2)
Dear Editor:
Please excuse me for taking some of your time.
I submitted a manuscript entitled “。 。。?!?(Ref. No. 。。) to ***about ** weeks ago. However, we have not yet receivedyour decisionon our manuscript till now. Could you please do me afavor to checkthe reviewing process of our manuscript?
Thank you very much for your time andconsideration.
Sincerely yours,
本站僅提供存儲(chǔ)服務(wù),所有內(nèi)容均由用戶(hù)發(fā)布,如發(fā)現(xiàn)有害或侵權(quán)內(nèi)容,請(qǐng)
點(diǎn)擊舉報(bào)。